How Much Will the Project Cost?
Many homeowners believe that if they know the square footage of a construction project, they can get a rough estimate of the cost. There are renovation calculators online that use square footage, and homeowners often think a contractor or architect can quote based on “dollars per square foot.”
At the beginning of a project, square footage estimates can serve a useful purpose for estimating project costs. They provide homeowners with a quick ballpark figure to help determine whether their renovation or addition is even feasible within their desired budget range. For example, if a local contractor explains that typical interior renovations in the area cost around $150–$200 per square foot, a homeowner can do simple math to understand whether a 500-square-foot project might land closer to $75,000–$100,000. This kind of rough estimate helps families decide if they’re financially ready to proceed, or if they should scale back the project size before investing in detailed design. However, while square footage is a helpful starting point, it should never be relied upon as an accurate estimate of cost.
The fact is, no contractor or architect can give an accurate cost estimate until a project has completed construction drawings. Until then, any number you get is tentative at best, and is useful only as a rough ballpark. To have an accurate understanding of project costs, homeowners need to go from vague estimates to real costs.
The challenges with cost-per-square-foot
Estimating via square footage masks many of the variables that can swing costs dramatically. There are several reasons why relying on square footage is risky:
1. Different spaces, different costs
A kitchen or a bathroom is usually much more expensive per square foot than a bedroom or family room. Why? Because of fixtures (cabinets, sinks, appliances), plumbing and electrical work, tile, ventilation, etc. A bedroom or family room that is simply floor, walls, and overhead lighting is far less complex.
2. Site, structural, and foundation variations
Additions that require new foundations, modifications to load-bearing walls, roof extensions, or structural upgrades cost more than interior renovations that work with your home’s existing framing. Also, soil conditions, terrain, or local weather load requirements may force more robust foundations or drainage, all of which add cost and are site-specific factors that square-foot-based estimates often ignore.
3. Quality and finish levels
Material choice makes a huge difference—flooring type, cabinetry style, window quality, and finishes, like trim, tile, and lighting all have different costs. Two projects with identical square footage can differ widely depending on whether you choose high-end custom materials or cost-conscious, “builder-grade” finishes. Finishes and fixtures heavily influence actual cost, and are not captured by a raw square-foot metric.
4. Hidden costs and unknowns
Unknown costs can also arise during renovation projects, especially in renovations of older structures. Hidden rot, outdated wiring or plumbing, code compliance issues, permit delays, or other structural surprises are unfortunately too common during construction projects. These are exactly the kinds of things square footage does not capture. Without fully developed drawings and site investigations, these unknowns are only speculative possibilities but can quickly become very real.
To help homeowners take these challenges and variations into consideration when budgeting, our firm has developed a proprietary renovation calculator that blends square footage with real-world factors about your specific project. In addition to using your home’s square footage, our calculator also considers the number of windows, total length of foundation walls, anticipated beam sizes, and other high-cost variables about your project when calculating an estimate. And while this is still a preliminary estimate, we help our clients get an idea of costs based on their project’s unique needs while our team produces final construction drawings.
Why homeowners need precise construction drawings
Given the realities above, there are some key steps homeowners should take to avoid costly surprises.
Remember that early estimates are only rough numbers: Before construction drawings are finished, any cost estimate you get is preliminary. It’s valuable for budgeting, but will likely vary up or down when the final construction drawings and bidding are completed.
Choose your desired materials and finishes: If possible, decide early what level of finishes, fixtures, windows, etc., you want. Different finishes will carry higher price tags, with higher-end materials costing more. For example: windows can vary in cost $600 to $1,500 installed depending on size, glazing, frame, and style. Balance your budget by investing in higher-quality items in areas of your home that are of high importance, such as the kitchen or primary bedroom, and save on areas of lower priority, such as a hall or second bath.
Require complete drawings before bidding: Never commit to a contractor’s price without full construction drawings. If someone tries to give you a guaranteed price too early, ask them for more detail about their assumptions (materials, structural work, site conditions, etc.).
Get multiple bids: Different contractors will see things differently—material costs, labor rates, sequencing, subcontractors. Comparing several bids can not only help you find a better price, but also reveal areas where an estimate is vague or something might be missing.
Factor in contingencies: Even with quality construction drawings and accurate bids, unexpected costs come up. A good rule of thumb is to set aside a contingency budget (often 10-20%) for things that weren’t visible at first or unplanned surprises that arise.
While square footage can provide a quick starting point for homeowners exploring the cost of a renovation or addition, it is only a rough guideline and should never be mistaken for an accurate estimate. Real costs depend on room type, finishes, site conditions, and hidden challenges, and the only way to get an accurate estimate is with complete construction drawings and competitive bids.
At Keith A. Kirsch Architect, we help our clients move beyond square-foot pricing with site-specific estimates while creating high-quality construction drawings that help homeowners protect their budget and ensure a smoother, more successful project.
Reach out to us with your project details, and we’ll share how our site-specific calculations can help you understand your project budget.
Other common questions
-
What makes 3D modeling so important?
-
Why choose an architect over a contractor?
-
Can I draw my own house plans?
Let’s Work Together
We’re always looking for new opportunities and are comfortable working internationally. Please get in touch and one of our project managers will contact you about beginning the proposal process.
